At-will Employment Isn't A Free Pass

A lot of business owners breathe a little easier when they hear the term “at-will employment.” In Florida, like most states, employment is “at-will” by default—meaning you can terminate an employee at any time, for any reason (or no reason), as long as it’s not illegal.

But here’s the catch: at-will doesn’t mean “no rules.” It doesn’t mean you can skip documentation, ignore performance issues, or handle terminations informally. And it definitely doesn’t protect you from wrongful termination claims, unemployment disputes, or EEOC complaints.

As a fractional HR consultant working with small businesses across Florida, I can’t count the number of times I’ve heard,

“But we’re an at-will state—I thought I didn’t need a paper trail!”

Let’s bust that myth right now.

What At-Will Employment Does Mean

• You can terminate the employment relationship at any time, with or without cause.
• You don’t need to give advance notice (though 2 weeks is standard for professionalism).
• Employees can also quit at any time, with or without notice.

What It Doesn’t Mean

❌ You can fire someone for a discriminatory reason
❌ You don’t need to follow your own company policies
❌ You can avoid unemployment claims or lawsuits without evidence
❌ You’re off the hook for retaliation, harassment, or ADA violations

At-will employment won’t save you in court if the perception is that the termination was unfair, retaliatory, or inconsistent.

Here's What You Still Need to Document—Every Time

1. Performance Conversations

Whenever you address performance, tardiness, attitude, or other issues—document it. Include:

• Date of the conversation
• What was discussed
• What expectations were set
• What consequences were communicated

Even a short email to yourself or a note in their file is better than nothing.

2. Policy Violations

If an employee violates a policy (even a minor one), note:

• What happened
• When it happened
• What action you took (verbal warning, written warning, etc.)

Consistency is key. If you make exceptions for some employees and not others, you're opening the door to discrimination claims.

3. Complaints and Investigations

If an employee makes a complaint—especially about harassment, discrimination, or safety—take it seriously. Investigate and document your steps, even if the complaint seems minor.

4. Disciplinary Actions

Whether it's a formal write-up or a coaching conversation, always:

• Be clear about what behavior is expected
• Give the employee a chance to respond
• Include a plan for follow-up or improvement

5. Termination Decisions

When it’s time to part ways:

• Outline the reason(s) for termination
• Tie it to documented performance or conduct
• Note if the employee received prior warnings
• Confirm if it violates any written policy

And please—never terminate in anger. Take time to document the “why” before you have the final conversation.

Florida-Specific Risks to Watch Out For

Florida may be employer-friendly, but you’re still subject to:

• Federal anti-discrimination laws (Title VII, ADA, ADEA, etc.)
• Florida Civil Rights Act
• Whistleblower protections
• Workers’ compensation retaliation laws

And if you have even one employee, you could be on the hook for unemployment claims—especially if you don’t have documentation to back your decision.

Why This Matters (Even With a Small Team)

The smaller the team, the more personal things feel—and the more likely a termination might trigger a complaint or claim. If you can’t show that you treated the employee fairly, consistently, and in accordance with your own policies, you’re vulnerable.

That’s why I help my clients create:

• Simple performance documentation templates
• Clear, concise handbooks (yes, even for five-person teams)
• A legally sound termination checklist
• HR support when hard conversations come up

Final Thought

At-will employment is not a shield. It’s a legal framework—but it only works for you if you also do your part: documenting, communicating, and applying your policies consistently.

If you’re managing performance issues, considering a termination, or just want to protect your business before something goes wrong—I can help.

Let’s talk about how to build smart, compliant HR practices that protect you and support your team.

Erin Eilers | Eilers HR | Fractional HR Consultant for Florida-Based Businesses
Helping small teams run HR the right way—without the corporate bloat.

#FractionalHR #FloridaHR #SmallBusinessSupport #EmployeeDocumentation #TerminationChecklist #ComplianceMatters #HRConsulting #EilersHR